Follow on Bloglovin

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

so much love for acoustic versions. [acoustic versions]

when i was younger i was listening to music constantly. i was listening to music while i was doing my homework, while i was reading and, basically, during any activity imaginable. the first thing i did in the morning was turning on my cd player and i always fell asleep whilst listening to music. i also had the annoying habit of listening to a song i liked over and over again, which - i am sure - must have been hell for the rest of my family. i think it was for this reason that they got me a walkman when i was still really young. however, they did not think about the fact that - once i was equipped with a walkman - they would now just hear my lousy singing and whistling without any music to cover it up. well, sometimes in life things don't really work out the way one wanted them to. haha.
while i was, at that time, listening to everything i could get my hands on i slowly figured out what i really appreciate over the years. this does not mean that i have narrowed down the spectrum of what i listen to or focused on specific genres but rather developed a sense of what i like and dislike and i can articulate why that is better. if anything i continue to discover more and more diverse types of music. one thing that i also figured out is that if there is a live version of anything i'll go for that and that i like songs better when there is a certain rawness about them. i like it better when i can tell that there are musicians playing real instruments rather than when i get the feeling that i would like the song if only they stopped trying to make it "perfect" - "perfect" meaning: completely ruining the material by leaving a song without any character - a little earlier in the process. so many times i have listened to great acoustic versions, bought the album and ended up being so disappointed. often in the studio versions the palpable emotions that made me fall in love with a song in the first place were missing and everything seemed kind of toned down. i guess during concerts an artist has the audience around which intensifies his or her way of interpreting the song...
for all those reasons i was overwhelmed with the genius of balcony tv when i stumbled over their website a couple of years back. the concept forced bands to strip their music of everything that they couldn't bring out on the tiny balcony. simple as that. however, they still had the excitement and the enthusiasm of the presenters from balcony tv and the people inside the flat. plus, i guess, it was something that kind of stuck out of the touring routine. something that was different, it was not just another venue.
the concept apparently just worked and has been replicated so many times all around the globe, and there are also so many other innovative ideas, concepts and shows that bring out the best in artists and bands. i am always so excited when i stumble over something new that i thought maybe someone else will be enjoying some tips as well. so i will - over the next weeks - present some of my favorite shows.

and as a illustration of what i mean:
















the script is one of those bands that frustrate me because i really like their song writing and their musical skills and danny o'donoghue's voice but i just don't like the way their studio versions sound, so i never listen to their music unless i can find an acoustic version.

as a comparison:















i do not say it's not well done. it's just a bit much in my opinion, i can kind of feel the constructedness of it and the thought that went into every second of the song, how they used everything they got in order to make it "perfect". i just think that the song - without all the additional effects - has enough to offer. it's like a great photography which has been oversatured in the editing process and it's obvious that instead of bringing out the best in the raw material the editing process has rendered it looking artificial and fake. it is still a great picture but i do not enjoy it wholeheartedly because of the visibility of the "trying to make it look better". similarly, the "trying to make it sound better" of the song is too obvious - and too prominent - for me.

No comments:

Post a Comment